Can the High Income Child Benefit Charge be fixed?
Though it was introduced almost a decade ago in January 2013, many parents and guardians may still be unaware of the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC). This Child Benefit Tax applies to anyone earning more than £50,000 a year while claiming Child Benefit for a child in their household.
However, many workers who are used to being taxed through their employer’s PAYE system won’t realise that the government expects them to submit annual self-assessment tax returns for HICBC. This has led to HMRC sending hundreds of thousands of letters about suspected non-compliance, hitting families with surprise bills and fines during a time that’s already financially difficult for many.
The Office for Tax Simplification (OTS) has been extremely critical of the HICBC implementation, issuing recommendations for improvement that HMRC has yet to follow. The question is, can the Child Benefit Tax be fixed? Or are the problems with enforcing HICBC declarations and collecting HICBC payments only the tip of the iceberg? Should the government rethink the whole scheme?